Two sentences apart
Simple interest is calculated on the original amount, every period, forever.
Compound interest is calculated on the original amount plus all the interest added so far.
That is the whole distinction. Everything else follows from it.
The short-term case, where it barely matters
Take $10,000 at 5% for three years.
Simple: 10,000 × 0.05 × 3 = $1,500 in interest. You repay $11,500. Interest runs at a flat $500 a year, or about $1.37 a day.
Compound, annually: the balance grows to 10,000 × 1.05³ = $11,576.25, so the interest is $1,576.25.
The difference across three years is $76.25. On a five-figure loan, over three years, that is almost nothing — which is why the distinction gets waved away as a technicality.
The long-term case, where it decides everything
Run the same $10,000 at 5% for thirty years instead.
Simple produces $15,000 of interest — $500 a year, thirty times.
Compound produces about $33,219. The balance reaches roughly $43,219.
Same principal, same rate. The gap has gone from $76 to over $18,000, and it is still widening. That is the entire argument for starting a retirement account early, and the entire danger of a credit card balance you never quite clear.
Why the curve bends
In year one there is no accumulated interest, so the two methods produce an identical result. In year two, compounding earns interest on year one's $500. In year three it earns on the whole accumulated amount. Each year the base is bigger, so each year adds more than the last.
Simple interest draws a straight line. Compound interest draws a curve that starts almost flat and then climbs steeply. Most of the visible difference arrives in the final third of a long period, which is exactly why it is so easy to underestimate at the start.
Which one applies to you
Car loans, most personal loans and typical student loans accrue simple interest on the outstanding principal. Credit cards compound, usually daily, which is what makes a revolving balance so expensive relative to its headline rate. Savings accounts and investment returns compound too, in your favour this time.
Compounding frequency is a smaller lever than it sounds
Daily compounding sounds dramatically more aggressive than annual. At everyday rates it is not. Moving 5% from annual to monthly compounding lifts the effective annual rate to about 5.12%.
Worth understanding, but the rate and the number of years are doing almost all of the work.
Run your own numbers
FAQ
What is the formula for simple interest?
How is compound interest different?
Why is the difference so small over three years?
Which loans use simple interest?
Does compounding frequency matter much?
Sources
Primary references used for the figures and rules on this page.